soulberry wrote:The Ganga-Sammy comparison in the comments section appears fair but Sammy's edge might be his usefulness in ODIs. For Tests, no harm in asking for a comparison.
if in the first place he can get into the ODI team over Bravo, Polard, Russell, Ravi, David Bernard, Dwayne Smith etc...to demonstrate that possible ODI edge.
and then again as captain too. he is not as good and experienced as Ganga as a captain. so far he may have a popular edge on Ganga for it may be that Ganga is not so popular with the players at the top...and he Sammy, has just started.
but if winning is the key, the point and purpse of the exercise of running, organising and playing the game, then you take your best shot at all times...which in captain C means Ganga
not Sammy, who can make the side only in the absence of 3-5 players with similair skill sets, all better that he